Index
Part 1: Understanding the Basics of Settlement Agreement Tax-Free Payments
Part 2: Post-Employment Notice Pay (PENP) and Taxable Payments in Settlement Agreements
Part 3: Redundancy Payments, Pension Payments, and Additional Exemptions in Settlement Agreements
Part 4: Legal and Practical Considerations When Negotiating a Settlement Agreement
Part 5: HMRC Audits, Compliance, and Recent Changes in Settlement Agreement Tax Treatment
Understanding the Basics of Settlement Agreement Tax-Free Payments
A settlement agreement, often referred to as a compromise agreement, is a legally binding contract between an employee and an employer, typically used when employment comes to an end. The agreement usually resolves any potential disputes, waiving the employee's right to take further legal action, in exchange for compensation. One of the most important aspects of this agreement, especially for UK taxpayers, is the tax treatment of the payments received.
In the UK, settlement agreements are not inherently tax-free. However, under specific conditions, part of the payment can be exempt from tax, particularly the first £30,000 of compensation. This part is often referred to as an 'ex gratia' payment, meaning it is given voluntarily by the employer and is not contractual or based on entitlement. To understand how this works and how it can benefit employees, it's essential to break down the different components of a settlement agreement and their respective tax treatments.
What is a Settlement Agreement?
A settlement agreement is a formal document drawn up between an employee and their employer when the employment relationship is being terminated. These agreements are common in redundancy situations, dismissals, or when there's a risk of a dispute, such as unfair dismissal claims. The employer offers the employee a settlement in exchange for signing the agreement, thereby waiving their rights to make future claims.
For employees, a critical question often arises: how will the money received under this agreement be taxed? This is where UK tax laws come into play.
The £30,000 Tax-Free Limit: What Does It Cover?
The most significant relief provided under UK tax law is that the first £30,000 of a settlement payment can be received tax-free. This rule is established under section 401 of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003. However, it's important to note that not all payments within a settlement agreement qualify for this tax exemption.
Ex Gratia Payments: Payments made as a form of compensation for loss of office, often termed 'ex gratia', are usually eligible for the tax-free treatment up to £30,000. Ex gratia means that the employer is not obliged to make the payment under the employee's contract, but is instead making a voluntary payment to settle potential legal claims.
Contractual Payments: Payments that are due to the employee under their employment contract, such as salary, notice pay, and accrued holiday pay, do not fall within the tax-free allowance. These payments are subject to the normal deductions for Income Tax and National Insurance Contributions (NICs).
To clarify further:
Termination Payments: If the payment compensates for loss of office, it falls within the scope of section 401 and can qualify for the £30,000 tax-free limit.
Contractual Entitlements: Any payments that the employee would have received as part of their normal salary or benefits package, even if included in the settlement agreement, are taxable. These include:
Salary payments up to the termination date
Payment in lieu of notice (PILON)
Accrued but untaken holiday pay
How Does the Tax-Free Payment Work in Practice?
Let’s consider an example to illustrate how the tax-free portion of a settlement agreement works in practice.
Example Scenario: Jane works for a company and earns £50,000 per year. Her employer decides to terminate her contract and offers her a settlement agreement. Under the terms of the settlement, Jane is offered:
£10,000 in salary (which covers her final month's pay)
£5,000 in payment for unused holiday days
£40,000 as an ex gratia payment for loss of office
How would these payments be taxed?
Salary and Holiday Pay: Both the £10,000 salary and £5,000 holiday pay are contractual entitlements and will be subject to Income Tax and National Insurance deductions, just like any other pay.
Ex Gratia Payment: The £40,000 ex gratia payment is partly eligible for the tax-free allowance. The first £30,000 of this amount will be tax-free, meaning Jane will not need to pay tax on it. However, the remaining £10,000 will be taxed according to her usual tax rate.
In summary, the £30,000 tax-free limit applies only to the ex gratia payment, while the other components of the settlement are taxed as normal income. This means that Jane’s total taxable income from the settlement would be £25,000 (£10,000 salary + £5,000 holiday pay + £10,000 of the ex gratia payment exceeding the £30,000 limit).
The Importance of Structuring the Settlement Agreement Properly
Understanding the various tax implications of a settlement agreement is crucial, as the way the agreement is structured can have a significant impact on the tax liability. Employers and employees alike should seek professional advice to ensure that the settlement agreement is drafted in a way that maximizes the employee’s tax relief.
For instance, if payments are not clearly designated in the agreement, HMRC may take the view that all or part of the settlement is taxable. Clear distinctions between different types of payments (e.g., compensatory vs. contractual) should be made in the agreement to avoid unnecessary tax liabilities.
Recent Developments and HMRC's Stance in 2024
As of 2024, HMRC has continued to scrutinize settlement agreements to ensure that they are not being used to avoid paying tax on what should be taxable income. In recent years, there has been a tightening of the rules around how termination payments are treated, particularly with the introduction of the Post-Employment Notice Pay (PENP) rules in 2018. These rules ensure that notice pay is always taxable, regardless of whether the payment is made as part of a settlement agreement or as a stand-alone payment.
Employees should be aware that attempting to disguise taxable income as part of a tax-free settlement can result in penalties and further scrutiny from HMRC. Therefore, it is essential to work with experienced professionals when negotiating and drafting a settlement agreement to ensure compliance with tax regulations.
Post-Employment Notice Pay (PENP) and Taxable Payments in Settlement Agreements
In the previous section, we explored the basics of how settlement agreements work in the UK, especially the £30,000 tax-free allowance on ex gratia payments. Now, it’s time to delve deeper into some of the more complex aspects of settlement agreements, particularly Post-Employment Notice Pay (PENP) and the various types of taxable payments that employees need to be aware of. Understanding these components is crucial for anyone involved in negotiating or agreeing to a settlement, as it helps in structuring the agreement to minimize tax liabilities while complying with UK tax law.
What is Post-Employment Notice Pay (PENP)?
Post-Employment Notice Pay (PENP) is one of the key elements that affects the tax treatment of payments in a settlement agreement. Introduced by HMRC in 2018, PENP refers to the amount of pay an employee would have received if they had worked their full notice period, instead of leaving immediately. The purpose of PENP is to prevent employees and employers from manipulating settlement agreements to make notice pay appear as part of the tax-free compensation payment.
Before the introduction of PENP rules, some settlement agreements allowed for payments that should have been treated as notice pay to be classified as part of the £30,000 tax-free compensation. This led to the loss of significant tax revenue for the government. To combat this, HMRC introduced the PENP regulations, which ensure that any pay related to the notice period is always taxable.
How Does PENP Work?
PENP is essentially a calculation that determines how much of the payment an employee receives in a settlement agreement should be treated as taxable income, based on the notice period they were entitled to but did not work. The formula is relatively straightforward, but understanding how it works in practice is essential for both employees and employers.
Here is the formula used to calculate PENP:
PENP = (BP x D) ÷ P - T
Where:
BP = Basic Pay (the employee’s monthly basic salary before any deductions, such as pension contributions or bonuses)
D = Number of days of notice the employee should have worked
P = Number of days in the pay period (typically 30 or 31 days)
T = The amount of any payment already made in respect of the notice period
Let’s break this down with an example.
Example of PENP Calculation
Scenario: Jack is an employee who earns £3,000 per month (basic salary) and has a three-month notice period in his contract. However, his employer terminates his contract immediately and offers him a settlement agreement that includes a lump sum payment. The employer has offered Jack an ex gratia payment of £50,000, which includes payment for his notice period.
In this case, the employer must calculate how much of the £50,000 settlement should be treated as PENP and therefore subject to tax. Let’s assume Jack’s notice period was three months (90 days), but he was not required to work this period.
Using the formula for PENP:
Basic Pay (BP): £3,000 (Jack’s monthly salary)
Number of Days (D): 90 days (since Jack has a 3-month notice period)
Days in the Pay Period (P): 30 days (assuming Jack is paid monthly)
T: £0 (no payment has been made for his notice period yet)
Now we can calculate the PENP:
PENP = (£3,000 x 90) ÷ 30 - 0
PENP = £9,000
Therefore, £9,000 of the £50,000 settlement payment will be treated as PENP and will be subject to tax, as it represents the pay Jack would have received if he had worked his full notice period.
Taxable Payments in Settlement Agreements
Settlement agreements often contain several different types of payments, and it's critical to distinguish between those that are taxable and those that are not. In addition to the PENP discussed above, other payments included in a settlement agreement may also be taxable, depending on their nature. Let’s break down the common types of payments you may encounter in a settlement agreement and explain whether they are taxable or tax-free.
1. Salary Payments
Any salary payments made up to the termination date are fully taxable as normal income. This includes the employee’s final salary and any payments for work completed up to the termination date. These payments are subject to Income Tax and National Insurance Contributions (NICs) in the usual way.
Example: Sarah earns £2,500 per month and is paid her final salary in her settlement agreement. This amount will be taxed at her normal tax rate and will also be subject to NICs.
2. Payment in Lieu of Notice (PILON)
Payment in Lieu of Notice (PILON) is another common payment found in settlement agreements. PILON is made when an employee is not required to work their notice period but receives payment for it instead. Under the PENP rules, PILON is always taxable as it represents pay that the employee would have received had they worked their notice period.
Example: Tom is entitled to a two-month notice period but is not required to work it. His employer offers him a PILON of £5,000 (equivalent to two months’ salary). This payment is fully taxable as it represents salary that Tom would have earned during his notice period.
3. Accrued Holiday Pay
Accrued holiday pay is compensation for any unused holiday entitlement the employee may have at the time of their termination. This payment is considered part of the employee’s normal earnings and is therefore fully taxable.
Example: If Rebecca has 10 days of unused holiday at the time of her termination, and her daily rate of pay is £200, she will receive £2,000 in accrued holiday pay. This amount is subject to tax and NICs, just like her regular salary.
4. Bonus Payments
If the employee is entitled to any bonuses under their employment contract, these payments are taxable as normal income. Whether the bonus is paid as part of the settlement agreement or separately, it will still be subject to tax.
Example: John is entitled to a £10,000 performance bonus under his contract. Even if this bonus is included in his settlement agreement, it will still be taxed as part of his income for that tax year.
5. Benefits in Kind
Some employees may receive non-cash benefits as part of their employment package, such as company cars, private healthcare, or other perks. If these benefits continue after the employee’s termination, they may be treated as taxable income.
Example: Maria’s settlement agreement allows her to keep her company car for three months after her termination. The value of the car for those three months may be treated as a taxable benefit, and Maria may have to pay tax on the value of this benefit.
Ex Gratia Payments: A Tax-Free Opportunity
As mentioned earlier, ex gratia payments are compensation payments made voluntarily by the employer, and they are often eligible for the £30,000 tax-free allowance. This is a crucial aspect of any settlement agreement, as it can significantly reduce the employee’s tax liability.
However, it’s important to note that only the first £30,000 of an ex gratia payment is tax-free. Any amount above this will be subject to tax, just like other income. This tax-free threshold can include redundancy payments and other compensatory payments made for loss of office or employment.
Example of Tax-Free Ex Gratia Payments
Scenario: Lisa is being made redundant and has been offered a settlement agreement that includes a £25,000 ex gratia payment and £10,000 for accrued holiday pay. How much of this will be tax-free?
The £25,000 ex gratia payment falls below the £30,000 tax-free limit, so it will not be subject to tax.
The £10,000 holiday pay is taxable as normal income.
In this case, Lisa benefits from the full tax-free allowance on her ex gratia payment, but the holiday pay is taxed.
Potential Tax Pitfalls
Employees should be cautious when negotiating a settlement agreement, as improper structuring of payments can lead to higher tax liabilities. For example, if a payment that should be treated as taxable salary is incorrectly classified as an ex gratia payment, HMRC may later audit the agreement and impose additional tax penalties. To avoid such situations, it’s advisable to work with a solicitor or tax advisor who can ensure the agreement is structured correctly and complies with all tax regulations.
Redundancy Payments, Pension Payments, and Additional Exemptions in Settlement Agreements
In the previous sections, we explored how different components of a settlement agreement are taxed, including Post-Employment Notice Pay (PENP), Payment in Lieu of Notice (PILON), and ex gratia payments. Now, we will focus on two specific aspects of settlement agreements that often arise in redundancy situations—redundancy payments and pension payments—and discuss the additional tax reliefs and exemptions available to employees. Understanding how these payments work is essential for ensuring you maximize your tax benefits while staying compliant with HMRC rules.
Redundancy Payments and Their Tax Treatment
One of the most common situations in which settlement agreements are used is redundancy. Redundancy occurs when an employer needs to reduce their workforce, and employees are terminated because their positions are no longer necessary. Redundancy payments are a form of compensation given to employees who lose their jobs due to redundancy.
In the UK, redundancy payments can be divided into two categories: statutory redundancy pay and contractual (or enhanced) redundancy pay. These payments are treated differently for tax purposes, and it’s important to understand how each category fits within the overall settlement agreement.
Statutory Redundancy Pay
Statutory redundancy pay is the minimum amount an employer is legally required to pay an employee who is being made redundant. The amount an employee is entitled to depends on several factors, including their length of service, age, and weekly pay (up to a certain limit).
As of 2024, the statutory redundancy pay rates are calculated as follows:
0.5 week’s pay for each full year of employment where the employee was under 22 years old.
1 week’s pay for each full year of employment between the ages of 22 and 41.
1.5 weeks’ pay for each full year of employment when the employee is 41 years old or older.
The weekly pay used in these calculations is capped, and the cap is adjusted periodically. For example, the weekly pay cap for statutory redundancy calculations in 2024 is £571. This means that even if an employee’s actual weekly pay is higher than £571, the statutory redundancy payment is calculated based on the capped figure.
Tax Treatment of Statutory Redundancy Pay:
The good news for employees is that statutory redundancy payments are entirely tax-free up to the £30,000 limit, just like ex gratia payments. This means that if your statutory redundancy payment falls below £30,000, you will not be required to pay any tax on it.
Example of Statutory Redundancy Pay
Scenario: Peter has been working for his company for 15 years and is 45 years old. His weekly pay is £600, but because of the statutory cap, his weekly pay for redundancy calculations is capped at £571. Based on his age and length of service, Peter is entitled to:
1.5 weeks’ pay for each year of service (because he is over 41 years old).
The calculation is as follows:
15 years x 1.5 weeks = 22.5 weeks of pay.
22.5 weeks x £571 (capped weekly pay) = £12,847.50.
Peter will receive £12,847.50 as his statutory redundancy payment, which is entirely tax-free because it falls well within the £30,000 limit.
Contractual (Enhanced) Redundancy Pay
In addition to statutory redundancy pay, many employers offer contractual (or enhanced) redundancy pay as part of the terms of employment or a collective agreement. This payment is usually higher than the statutory amount and is provided as an additional benefit to employees who are being made redundant.
While statutory redundancy payments are automatically tax-free up to the £30,000 threshold, contractual redundancy pay is treated differently. Contractual redundancy pay counts toward the £30,000 tax-free limit, but any amount that exceeds this threshold will be subject to tax.
Example of Contractual Redundancy Pay
Scenario: Peter’s employer offers him an enhanced redundancy package, which includes an additional £20,000 as part of his redundancy settlement, on top of his statutory redundancy pay of £12,847.50. This means Peter will receive a total of:
£12,847.50 (statutory redundancy) + £20,000 (contractual redundancy) = £32,847.50.
Because the first £30,000 of a redundancy payment is tax-free, Peter will not pay tax on the statutory £12,847.50 or the first £17,152.50 of his contractual redundancy payment. However, the remaining £2,847.50 will be taxed as income at Peter’s usual tax rate.
Pension Payments in Settlement Agreements
Another important consideration for employees entering into a settlement agreement is the treatment of pension payments. If an employee is entitled to pension contributions from their employer, these contributions may continue even after the employment has been terminated, depending on the terms of the settlement agreement.
Employer Pension Contributions
In many cases, employers continue to make contributions to an employee’s pension fund as part of the settlement agreement. These contributions are generally considered a tax-free benefit, as long as they are made directly to the employee’s pension provider and not paid to the employee in cash.
It’s important to note that pension contributions made as part of a settlement agreement do not count towards the £30,000 tax-free limit. This means that even if your employer contributes to your pension fund as part of the settlement, these contributions can be made tax-free, provided they are structured properly.
Example of Pension Contributions
Scenario: Emma’s employer offers her a settlement agreement that includes a £10,000 ex gratia payment and an additional £5,000 to be contributed to her pension fund. In this case:
The £10,000 ex gratia payment will be counted towards the £30,000 tax-free limit.
The £5,000 pension contribution is made directly to Emma’s pension provider and does not count towards the £30,000 tax-free limit.
This structure allows Emma to benefit from the full £10,000 ex gratia payment tax-free, and the £5,000 pension contribution will also remain tax-free, as it is not considered part of her taxable income.
Taking a Pension Lump Sum
In some cases, an employee may be entitled to take a pension lump sum as part of their settlement agreement. Under UK pension rules, individuals can withdraw up to 25% of their pension savings as a tax-free lump sum once they reach the age of 55 (this is subject to change depending on government regulations). However, this lump sum must be carefully coordinated with the settlement agreement, as any excess over 25% will be subject to tax.
If an employee chooses to take a pension lump sum in conjunction with a settlement agreement, it’s essential to work with a financial advisor to ensure that the withdrawal is tax-efficient and compliant with both pension and settlement rules.
Additional Exemptions and Tax Reliefs
In addition to the £30,000 tax-free limit for ex gratia and redundancy payments, there are other exemptions and tax reliefs that may apply in specific circumstances. Understanding these reliefs can help employees reduce their overall tax liability when entering into a settlement agreement.
Injury to Feelings Payments
In some settlement agreements, employees receive compensation for injury to feelings, which can arise from claims related to discrimination, harassment, or unfair treatment. These payments are made as a form of non-financial compensation and are intended to compensate the employee for the emotional distress they have suffered.
HMRC allows injury to feelings payments to be made tax-free, provided that they are not related to the termination of employment. If the payment is linked to a claim for discrimination that occurred before the termination, it can be treated as a tax-free payment. However, if the injury to feelings payment is directly linked to the termination itself, it will count towards the £30,000 tax-free limit.
Example of Injury to Feelings Payments
Scenario: Lucy files a discrimination claim against her employer and agrees to a settlement that includes £15,000 in compensation for injury to feelings, in addition to £20,000 for redundancy. In this case:
The £15,000 for injury to feelings is related to events that occurred before Lucy’s employment was terminated, so it can be treated as a tax-free payment.
The £20,000 redundancy payment will count towards the £30,000 tax-free limit, meaning Lucy will not have to pay tax on any part of this settlement.
Foreign Service Exemption
Another valuable tax relief is the foreign service exemption, which applies to employees who have spent a significant portion of their employment working abroad. Under this exemption, employees who have worked outside the UK for part or all of their employment may be entitled to additional tax relief on their settlement payments.
The foreign service exemption can apply if:
The employee has been working abroad for at least part of their employment, and
The settlement payment relates to compensation for the loss of employment.
If an employee qualifies for the foreign service exemption, some or all of their settlement payment may be treated as tax-free, in addition to the standard £30,000 allowance.
Example of Foreign Service Exemption
Scenario: David has worked for a multinational company for 10 years, with 5 of those years spent working abroad. When David is made redundant, he receives a £40,000 settlement payment. Because David has spent a significant portion of his employment working outside the UK, he may be entitled to the foreign service exemption, which could reduce the taxable portion of his settlement beyond the £30,000 threshold.
In this case, David’s foreign service exemption could allow him to receive the entire £40,000 tax-free, depending on the specifics of his foreign service.
Legal and Practical Considerations When Negotiating a Settlement Agreement
As we have discussed in the previous sections, settlement agreements in the UK can be complex, particularly when considering the various tax implications and payment structures involved. However, beyond the technical aspects of tax treatment, there are several legal and practical considerations that both employees and employers need to take into account when negotiating and finalizing a settlement agreement.
This section will explore some of the critical legal factors to consider, common pitfalls to avoid, and best practices for structuring payments in a way that benefits the employee while remaining compliant with HMRC regulations. We will also discuss the importance of seeking professional advice and how to handle disputes that may arise during the negotiation process.
Legal Framework Governing Settlement Agreements
Settlement agreements are governed by employment law in the UK, and their use is strictly regulated. They are designed to be legally binding contracts that settle any disputes between the employer and the employee, often in exchange for compensation. For a settlement agreement to be legally binding, it must meet several key criteria:
Written Agreement: The settlement must be in writing.
Independent Legal Advice: The employee must have received independent legal advice on the terms and effects of the agreement, particularly regarding their ability to pursue claims in the future.
Advisor Certification: The advisor who provides legal advice must be identified in the agreement, and they must be insured to provide such advice.
Full and Final Settlement: The agreement must clearly specify that it is in full and final settlement of any claims the employee may have against the employer.
Reference to Applicable Laws: The agreement must reference the relevant employment legislation that governs settlement agreements (e.g., the Employment Rights Act 1996).
If any of these criteria are not met, the settlement agreement may not be legally enforceable. This makes it essential for employees to receive professional legal advice before signing any agreement.
Example of Legal Requirements in Practice
Scenario: Ben works for a large corporation, and his employment is being terminated as part of a redundancy process. His employer offers him a settlement agreement that includes a £25,000 ex gratia payment and a £5,000 payment in lieu of notice. Ben is asked to sign the agreement immediately.
In this situation, Ben cannot simply sign the agreement without first receiving independent legal advice. If he does so, the agreement will not be legally binding. The company must provide Ben with the opportunity to consult a solicitor, who will review the terms of the agreement and advise Ben on whether it is fair and whether any potential claims he may have (e.g., for unfair dismissal or discrimination) are being properly addressed.
Once Ben has received this advice and the solicitor has certified the agreement, Ben can sign the settlement, and it will become legally binding.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid When Negotiating a Settlement Agreement
Negotiating a settlement agreement is a critical process that can significantly impact the employee’s financial position. There are several common pitfalls that both employers and employees should be aware of to ensure the settlement is fair and tax-efficient.
1. Misclassification of Payments
One of the most common mistakes made in settlement agreements is the misclassification of payments. For example, if a payment that should be classified as a contractual payment (such as a salary payment or Payment in Lieu of Notice) is incorrectly labeled as an ex gratia payment, this can lead to issues with HMRC and a higher tax liability for the employee.
Example: If Jane’s settlement agreement includes a £10,000 payment that her employer refers to as an ex gratia payment, but it is actually compensation for unused holiday pay, HMRC may later determine that this amount should have been taxed as income. Jane could face additional tax liabilities and potentially penalties for underpaid taxes.
To avoid this, it is crucial to ensure that each payment in the settlement agreement is properly categorized and that the agreement clearly distinguishes between taxable and non-taxable payments.
2. Unrealistic Timelines for Payment
Another common issue arises when employers include unrealistic timelines for making payments under the settlement agreement. For example, some employers may agree to make the payments within 28 days of signing the agreement, only to delay the actual payment.
Employees should ensure that the timeline for payment is reasonable and clearly stated in the agreement. If the payment is delayed, the employee may have to take legal action to enforce the agreement.
Example: Emma’s settlement agreement specifies that she will receive her ex gratia payment of £30,000 within 30 days of signing the agreement. However, 45 days pass, and she still has not received the payment. Emma may need to engage a solicitor to send a formal letter to her employer demanding payment, and in some cases, she may even need to take legal action to enforce the terms of the settlement.
3. Post-Employment Restrictions
Many settlement agreements include post-employment restrictions, such as non-compete clauses, non-solicitation clauses, or confidentiality agreements. These restrictions can have a significant impact on the employee’s future employment opportunities, and employees should carefully review these clauses before agreeing to them.
Non-compete clauses typically prevent the employee from working for a competitor for a specified period (e.g., six months or one year), while non-solicitation clauses may prevent the employee from contacting clients or colleagues from their previous job. Confidentiality clauses may restrict the employee from disclosing the terms of the settlement agreement to third parties.
Example of Post-Employment Restrictions
Scenario: Alex’s settlement agreement includes a non-compete clause that prevents him from working for any competitor in the same industry for 12 months. However, Alex works in a specialized industry with few employers, and agreeing to this clause would significantly limit his ability to find new employment.
Before signing the agreement, Alex should negotiate this clause with his employer. For example, he may ask to reduce the restriction period to six months or to limit the geographical scope of the restriction.
Structuring Payments to Minimize Tax Liabilities
One of the primary goals when negotiating a settlement agreement is to structure the payments in a way that minimizes the employee’s tax liability. As discussed in previous sections, some payments are eligible for tax relief, while others are taxable as income. Properly categorizing these payments and ensuring they are structured correctly can help employees avoid paying unnecessary taxes.
1. Maximizing the £30,000 Tax-Free Allowance
The £30,000 tax-free allowance is one of the most valuable benefits available to employees receiving a settlement payment. However, to maximize this allowance, it’s important to ensure that only eligible payments are counted towards the tax-free threshold.
Ex gratia payments, redundancy payments, and compensatory payments for loss of office can all count toward the £30,000 tax-free limit. However, any contractual payments, such as salary, notice pay, or holiday pay, must be taxed as income and do not benefit from this allowance.
Example of Structuring Payments for Maximum Tax Efficiency
Scenario: David’s settlement agreement includes the following payments:
£20,000 ex gratia payment for loss of office
£5,000 for accrued holiday pay
£10,000 Payment in Lieu of Notice (PILON)
To maximize his tax benefits, David’s solicitor advises structuring the settlement as follows:
The £20,000 ex gratia payment will be counted towards the £30,000 tax-free limit.
The £5,000 holiday pay and £10,000 PILON will be treated as taxable income and will be subject to tax at David’s usual rate.
This structure allows David to receive the full £20,000 ex gratia payment tax-free, while the other payments are treated as income and taxed accordingly.
2. Handling Post-Employment Benefits
As part of a settlement agreement, employees may be offered post-employment benefits, such as continued health insurance or company car use. These benefits are often treated as taxable income, and the value of the benefit may be subject to tax.
It’s important to consider how these benefits will be taxed and whether it makes sense to negotiate for an increased cash payment instead of non-cash benefits.
Example of Post-Employment Benefits
Scenario: Rebecca’s employer offers her the use of her company car for six months after her termination as part of her settlement agreement. The value of the benefit is £3,000. Rebecca consults her solicitor, who advises her that this benefit will be treated as taxable income. Instead of accepting the car benefit, Rebecca negotiates for an additional £3,000 cash payment, which can be treated as part of the overall settlement.
3. Pension Contributions
As we discussed in the previous section, pension contributions made by the employer as part of a settlement agreement are generally tax-free, provided they are paid directly into the employee’s pension fund. Employees should consider whether they would benefit from additional pension contributions as part of their settlement, as these contributions do not count toward the £30,000 tax-free limit.
Example of Pension Contributions
Scenario: John’s employer offers him a £50,000 settlement payment, including a £10,000 ex gratia payment and a £5,000 pension contribution. John’s solicitor advises him to negotiate for a higher pension contribution, as the pension payments are tax-free and do not count toward the £30,000 limit. John successfully negotiates an increase in the pension contribution to £10,000, allowing him to reduce his tax liability.
The Importance of Seeking Professional Advice
Given the complexity of settlement agreements and the tax implications involved, it is highly recommended that employees seek professional advice from both solicitors and tax advisors. Solicitors can ensure that the terms of the agreement are fair and legally binding, while tax advisors can help structure the payments in a way that maximizes tax efficiency.
Both parties should take the time to carefully review the agreement and consider how different elements of the settlement, such as redundancy payments, PILON, pension contributions, and post-employment benefits, will impact the employee’s financial position.
Example of the Importance of Professional Advice
Scenario: Claire is offered a settlement agreement by her employer that includes a £35,000 ex gratia payment and £10,000 PILON. Claire consults a solicitor, who advises her that the PILON will be fully taxable, and the excess over the £30,000 ex gratia payment will also be taxed. The solicitor helps Claire negotiate a more favorable structure, including an increased pension contribution, which reduces her overall tax liability.
HMRC Audits, Compliance, and Recent Changes in Settlement Agreement Tax Treatment
In the previous sections, we have covered the structure, legal requirements, and tax treatment of different types of payments within settlement agreements, including redundancy payments, ex gratia payments, and pension contributions. Now, we will focus on another critical aspect of settlement agreements: ensuring compliance with HMRC regulations and handling potential audits. In addition, we will explore recent changes in the law up to 2024 that impact the tax treatment of settlement agreements, providing an up-to-date guide on how to stay compliant with the ever-evolving tax regulations in the UK.
HMRC’s Role in Auditing Settlement Agreements
Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (HMRC) plays a central role in ensuring that settlement agreements comply with UK tax law, particularly regarding the correct classification of payments and the application of tax exemptions such as the £30,000 tax-free limit. Failure to comply with HMRC regulations can lead to audits, penalties, and additional tax liabilities, making it essential for employers and employees alike to structure settlement agreements carefully.
Why HMRC Audits Settlement Agreements
Settlement agreements, particularly those involving large payments or complex structures, are increasingly coming under scrutiny by HMRC. This is because certain payments, such as ex gratia compensation and redundancy payments, can qualify for tax exemptions, which may lead to the misclassification of other taxable payments to minimize tax liability. HMRC audits aim to ensure that:
Employers and employees are correctly classifying different types of payments.
The correct amount of tax has been paid on contractual entitlements, such as salary, notice pay, and bonuses.
The £30,000 tax-free limit is applied only to eligible payments, such as compensatory ex gratia payments or redundancy compensation.
Types of HMRC Audits
HMRC may carry out routine compliance checks or targeted audits in cases where it suspects non-compliance or tax avoidance. Routine checks are often part of broader audits of a company’s payroll or employee benefits, while targeted audits may focus specifically on the tax treatment of settlement agreements.
Example of a Targeted Audit by HMRC
Scenario: Sophie’s employer has entered into several high-value settlement agreements with employees, with many receiving payments that include both ex gratia compensation and Payment in Lieu of Notice (PILON). In one instance, Sophie’s employer classified a £40,000 payment as entirely ex gratia, despite the fact that £10,000 of the payment represented notice pay. HMRC conducts an audit and finds that the £10,000 PILON was incorrectly classified as ex gratia compensation, resulting in unpaid taxes. The company is required to pay backdated taxes and penalties for this misclassification.
Common Areas of Non-Compliance in Settlement Agreements
There are several common areas of non-compliance that HMRC may investigate when auditing settlement agreements:
Misclassification of Payments: As discussed earlier, it’s crucial that each payment is correctly classified as either taxable income (e.g., salary, notice pay) or tax-exempt compensation (e.g., ex gratia payments). Misclassifying taxable payments as ex gratia to avoid tax can result in penalties.
Failure to Report Taxable Benefits: Settlement agreements may include non-cash benefits, such as the continued use of a company car or health insurance, which must be reported as taxable benefits. Failure to report these benefits can trigger HMRC audits.
Incorrect Application of the £30,000 Tax-Free Limit: If an employee receives more than £30,000 in compensation payments (e.g., a combination of redundancy pay and ex gratia compensation), any amount above the threshold must be taxed. HMRC may audit agreements where this threshold has not been correctly applied.
How to Ensure Compliance and Avoid Audits
The best way to avoid an HMRC audit or penalties related to settlement agreements is to ensure full compliance with UK tax law. Both employers and employees should take proactive steps to structure the agreement correctly and report all payments and benefits accurately.
1. Accurate Classification of Payments
Ensure that all payments in the settlement agreement are correctly categorized. Payments that are contractual in nature, such as final salary payments, Payment in Lieu of Notice (PILON), and accrued holiday pay, should be treated as taxable income. Compensation for loss of office, redundancy payments, and ex gratia payments can qualify for tax exemptions, but only up to the £30,000 limit.
Example of Correct Payment Classification
Scenario: Liam’s settlement agreement includes a £25,000 ex gratia payment for loss of office and £8,000 in accrued holiday pay. Liam’s solicitor ensures that the £8,000 is treated as taxable income, while the £25,000 ex gratia payment is tax-free under the £30,000 allowance. By accurately classifying these payments, Liam avoids any issues with HMRC.
2. Clear Documentation
Ensure that the settlement agreement is clearly documented and that each payment is categorized and explained in detail. For example, if the payment includes both ex gratia compensation and PILON, the agreement should clearly state the amounts attributable to each category. Clear documentation will help avoid any misunderstandings with HMRC in the event of an audit.
Example of Clear Documentation
Scenario: Laura’s settlement agreement includes £20,000 ex gratia compensation, £5,000 in redundancy pay, and £10,000 PILON. Her solicitor advises her employer to break down these amounts in the agreement, with each payment clearly labeled. This ensures that the tax treatment is transparent and reduces the risk of an HMRC audit.
3. Use of Professional Advice
Employers and employees should seek professional advice when drafting and reviewing settlement agreements. Solicitors and tax advisors can ensure that the agreement is compliant with tax law, that payments are correctly structured to minimize tax liability, and that HMRC regulations are followed.
4. Reporting Benefits and Non-Cash Compensation
Ensure that any non-cash compensation or benefits, such as continued use of company assets (e.g., cars, laptops) or extended health insurance coverage, are properly reported as taxable benefits. These should be listed on the employee’s P11D form, which is used to report benefits in kind to HMRC.
Example of Reporting Non-Cash Benefits
Scenario: Rachel’s settlement agreement includes a six-month extension of her private health insurance coverage, worth £1,200. This benefit is taxable, and Rachel’s employer reports it on her P11D form. By correctly reporting the benefit, Rachel and her employer avoid penalties from HMRC.
What to Do if You Face an HMRC Audit
If HMRC audits your settlement agreement, it’s important to respond promptly and provide all requested information. Here are the steps to take if you receive notice of an HMRC audit:
1. Review the Agreement
Review the settlement agreement to ensure that all payments and benefits are correctly classified. If there are any areas of uncertainty, consult your solicitor or tax advisor to clarify the terms of the agreement.
2. Cooperate with HMRC
Provide HMRC with the information they request, including copies of the settlement agreement, tax returns, and any other documentation. Cooperating with HMRC will help resolve the audit more quickly and minimize the risk of penalties.
3. Negotiate with HMRC if Necessary
In some cases, HMRC may challenge the classification of certain payments. If you disagree with their assessment, your solicitor or tax advisor can negotiate with HMRC to reach a resolution. In some cases, you may need to pay back taxes or agree to a revised tax treatment for certain payments.
4. Appealing HMRC Decisions
If you disagree with HMRC’s decision after an audit, you may have the option to appeal. This process involves providing evidence to support your case and working with HMRC’s dispute resolution team to reach a final agreement.
Navigating the complexities of settlement agreements and their tax implications can be challenging, but by understanding the latest HMRC regulations, structuring payments carefully, and seeking professional advice, employees and employers can minimize their tax liabilities and ensure compliance. As HMRC continues to tighten its enforcement of tax rules surrounding settlement agreements, it’s more important than ever to ensure that agreements are clearly documented, payments are correctly classified, and all taxable benefits are properly reported.
By staying informed of the latest changes in tax law and working with legal and tax professionals, both parties can navigate settlement agreements with confidence, avoiding the risks of audits and penalties from HMRC.
Case Study: Settlement Agreement Tax-Free
Background
Meet Edward Thompson, a 45-year-old project manager based in London, who has worked for a mid-sized marketing consultancy for over 15 years. Due to a company restructuring process, Edward’s position was made redundant. Rather than leave the company and pursue legal action for potential claims, such as unfair dismissal, Edward was offered a settlement agreement. This agreement included both compensation for the loss of his job and a few additional elements, such as payment in lieu of notice and accrued holiday pay.
As Edward started exploring the details of the settlement agreement, his main concern was understanding the tax treatment of the payments involved. With the right advice, Edward could take advantage of the tax-free element of the settlement agreement, allowing him to maximize the value of his compensation without losing unnecessary amounts to tax.
Initial Offer and Breakdown of Payments
The initial settlement offer included a £50,000 lump sum, split into the following components:
Ex gratia payment (compensation for loss of office): £30,000
Payment in lieu of notice (PILON): £10,000
Accrued holiday pay: £5,000
Bonus (as per the employment contract): £5,000
Edward’s first step was to consult a solicitor specializing in employment law to ensure the agreement was fair and compliant with UK tax laws. The solicitor confirmed that the first £30,000 of the ex gratia payment could be received tax-free, but the other payments, including PILON, holiday pay, and bonus, were subject to Income Tax and National Insurance Contributions (NICs).
Understanding the Tax-Free Element
Edward’s solicitor explained that under section 401 of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003, the first £30,000 of compensation payments related to the loss of employment (often referred to as “ex gratia” or non-contractual payments) could be received tax-free. This meant that the £30,000 ex gratia payment would be entirely free from tax, as it fell within this limit.
On the other hand, payments like the PILON and holiday pay were contractual obligations and could not benefit from the tax-free allowance. These payments would be taxed as normal income.
Tax Calculations: Breaking It Down
Now, let’s break down the tax implications of Edward’s settlement agreement based on the figures provided. Here's how each element would be treated for tax purposes:
Ex gratia payment: £30,000 (Tax-free)
Since this payment represents compensation for the loss of office, and it falls under the £30,000 threshold, it is entirely tax-free. Edward would receive the full £30,000 without any deductions.
PILON: £10,000 (Taxable)
The payment in lieu of notice is treated as if it were salary. This means that Edward will be subject to Income Tax and NICs on the £10,000. Assuming Edward is a higher-rate taxpayer (earning over £50,270 annually), this would mean:
Income Tax at 40%: £4,000
NICs at 2% (for higher-rate taxpayers): £200
After deductions, Edward would receive £5,800 from the £10,000 PILON.
Accrued holiday pay: £5,000 (Taxable)
Similar to the PILON, the holiday pay is also treated as taxable income. Based on Edward’s tax bracket:
Income Tax at 40%: £2,000
NICs at 2%: £100
After deductions, Edward would receive £2,900 from the £5,000 accrued holiday pay.
Bonus: £5,000 (Taxable)
Edward’s annual bonus, though included in the settlement, is part of his contractual entitlement and is therefore subject to tax. The tax breakdown would be the same:
Income Tax at 40%: £2,000
NICs at 2%: £100
After deductions, Edward would receive £2,900 from the £5,000 bonus.
Final Payment Breakdown
After the deductions for tax and NICs, Edward’s final settlement would look like this:
Ex gratia payment: £30,000 (tax-free)
PILON: £5,800 (after deductions)
Accrued holiday pay: £2,900 (after deductions)
Bonus: £2,900 (after deductions)
Total amount Edward would receive after tax:£30,000 + £5,800 + £2,900 + £2,900 = £41,600
The Process of Negotiation
During the initial negotiations, Edward’s solicitor identified an important issue: Post-Employment Notice Pay (PENP). The solicitor calculated that since the PILON covered two months of Edward’s notice period, the amount was correct and taxable. However, the solicitor suggested Edward negotiate additional pension contributions from his employer, which would be tax-efficient.
Pension contributions made by the employer directly into Edward’s pension fund are typically tax-free, provided they don’t exceed annual contribution limits. Edward’s solicitor managed to secure an extra £5,000 contribution to his pension fund. This additional pension contribution would not be subject to Income Tax or NICs and would further benefit Edward in the long term.
Negotiating the Exit: Additional Considerations
Apart from the financial aspects, Edward’s settlement agreement also covered several non-financial components:
A Mutual Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA): Both parties agreed not to disclose the terms of the settlement to any third party.
An Agreed Reference: Edward’s solicitor negotiated that his employer would provide a neutral reference to any future employers, ensuring that the redundancy would not negatively affect his job prospects.
Outplacement Support: As part of the settlement, the company agreed to provide outplacement services, including CV workshops and interview coaching, to help Edward find new employment.
After the Settlement: Real-Life Steps
Once the settlement was finalized and signed by both parties, Edward’s employer processed the payments. HMRC was notified of the settlement, and Edward received the tax-free portion of his payment, along with the taxed portions of the PILON, holiday pay, and bonus.
Edward also arranged for the pension contribution to be paid into his workplace pension scheme, which was tax-free. His solicitor advised him to retain all documentation related to the settlement, including the breakdown of the payments and the agreement, in case of any future inquiries from HMRC.
Lessons Learned
By understanding the tax rules surrounding settlement agreements, particularly the £30,000 tax-free allowance, Edward was able to maximize his compensation while minimizing his tax liability. Here are the key takeaways from Edward’s experience:
Seek professional legal advice to ensure the settlement agreement is fair and tax-efficient.
Understand the tax treatment of each payment in the settlement—ex gratia payments can be tax-free up to £30,000, while PILON and other contractual payments are taxable.
Negotiate for additional benefits, such as pension contributions, which may be tax-free.
Keep detailed records of the settlement agreement in case of future HMRC audits.
Edward’s case is a perfect example of how a well-negotiated settlement agreement, paired with expert legal advice, can help employees in the UK take full advantage of the tax benefits available under current legislation.
FAQs
Q: Are all types of compensation payments in a settlement agreement tax-free?
A: No, only certain types of compensation payments, such as ex gratia payments for loss of office, are tax-free up to £30,000. Other payments like salary or holiday pay are taxable.
Q: Can you receive more than £30,000 tax-free if you have multiple settlement agreements in the same tax year?
A: No, the £30,000 tax-free limit applies to the total of all settlement payments received in the same tax year, not per agreement.
Q: Do settlement agreements include National Insurance (NI) contributions?
A: Yes, some payments like salary, PILON, and bonuses in settlement agreements are subject to National Insurance contributions.
Q: Is compensation for wrongful dismissal part of the £30,000 tax-free allowance?
A: No, compensation for wrongful dismissal is taxable and does not fall under the £30,000 tax-free limit.
Q: Does your age affect how much tax-free compensation you can receive in a settlement agreement?
A: No, the tax-free compensation limit of £30,000 applies regardless of your age.
Q: If you receive a settlement agreement after a long-term sickness absence, is it tax-free?
A: The tax treatment depends on the nature of the payment. Compensation related to injury or disability could be tax-exempt, but regular salary components are taxable.
Q: Does accepting a settlement agreement affect your ability to claim benefits like Universal Credit?
A: Yes, receiving a settlement payment may impact your eligibility for benefits such as Universal Credit, as it could be treated as income.
Q: Is holiday pay included in the £30,000 tax-free settlement agreement amount?
A: No, holiday pay is considered part of normal earnings and is fully taxable.
Q: Can you receive a tax-free settlement agreement payment if you continue working for the same employer?
A: No, tax-free settlement payments generally apply when the employment is terminated. Continuing to work for the employer usually disqualifies you from this benefit.
Q: Are payments made for injury to health in a settlement agreement tax-free?
A: Yes, payments for injury to health or disability arising from employment can be tax-exempt, provided they meet certain criteria.
Q: Do settlement agreements include statutory redundancy pay?
A: Yes, statutory redundancy pay is often part of a settlement agreement and is tax-free up to £30,000, provided other qualifying criteria are met.
Q: How does the tax-free allowance work for settlement agreements involving voluntary redundancy?
A: For voluntary redundancy, the £30,000 tax-free limit still applies to qualifying compensatory payments, just as it does for compulsory redundancy.
Q: Can you avoid paying tax on a settlement agreement by spreading payments over multiple tax years?
A: No, HMRC treats the total payment received in the tax year as a single amount, so spreading payments over multiple years will not help avoid taxes.
Q: Are settlement payments for unfair dismissal tax-free?
A: Compensation for unfair dismissal may be partially tax-free if it is compensatory and not contractual. However, amounts over £30,000 are taxable.
Q: What happens if you receive a settlement payment while on a zero-hours contract?
A: Payments like compensation for loss of office are still eligible for the £30,000 tax-free limit, but any pay for hours worked is taxable.
Q: Is a non-compete clause in a settlement agreement taxable?
A: Yes, compensation received for agreeing to a non-compete clause is typically taxable, as it is considered part of your earnings.
Q: Can you claim tax relief on legal fees for settlement agreements?
A: Yes, legal fees directly related to negotiating a settlement agreement may be tax-deductible if they are incurred in connection with securing your employment rights.
Q: If you take a settlement agreement, can you still claim Employment and Support Allowance (ESA)?
A: It depends on the amount of the settlement. A large settlement could affect your eligibility for means-tested benefits like ESA.
Q: Are bonuses included in the tax-free limit of a settlement agreement?
A: No, bonuses are considered part of your earnings and are subject to tax and National Insurance.
Q: Are severance payments made to directors subject to the £30,000 tax-free limit?
A: Yes, directors can also qualify for the £30,000 tax-free limit on compensatory payments for loss of office.
Q: Can you receive more than £30,000 tax-free if your settlement agreement spans multiple tax years?
A: No, the £30,000 tax-free limit is applied per tax year, but you cannot receive an additional £30,000 in subsequent years for the same agreement.
Q: Do settlement agreements that include shares or stock options fall under the tax-free limit?
A: No, shares and stock options are generally taxable as income and do not benefit from the £30,000 tax-free limit.
Q: Can you negotiate additional pension contributions as part of a settlement agreement?
A: Yes, pension contributions made by your employer as part of the settlement agreement can be negotiated and are usually tax-free.
Q: Is payment for unused annual leave taxable in a settlement agreement?
A: Yes, any payment for unused annual leave is treated as earnings and is subject to Income Tax and National Insurance.
Q: Are employers required to pay severance as part of a settlement agreement?
A: No, settlement agreements are voluntary, and the terms are negotiated between the employer and employee. Employers are not legally required to offer a settlement.
Q: Do you have to pay Capital Gains Tax on a settlement agreement payment?
A: No, settlement payments are subject to Income Tax, not Capital Gains Tax, as they relate to employment rather than the disposal of an asset.
Q: Can a settlement agreement include a reference to help with future employment?
A: Yes, many settlement agreements include a clause that provides the employee with a mutually agreed reference for future employment.
Q: Are payments for restrictive covenants in settlement agreements tax-free?
A: No, payments for restrictive covenants, such as non-compete agreements, are taxable as earnings.
Q: Is it mandatory to involve ACAS in a settlement agreement negotiation?
A: No, while ACAS can assist in resolving disputes, it is not mandatory to involve them in settlement agreement negotiations.
Q: Can you include tax indemnity clauses in a settlement agreement?
A: Yes, employers often include tax indemnity clauses in settlement agreements to protect themselves if HMRC later demands additional tax on the payment.
Q: Are death-in-service benefits part of the £30,000 tax-free settlement limit?
A: No, death-in-service benefits are usually paid through a life insurance policy and are typically not subject to Income Tax.
Q: Is a settlement agreement legally binding if you don’t seek independent legal advice?
A: No, a settlement agreement is not legally binding unless the employee has received independent legal advice about the terms and effects of the agreement.
Q: Can you request that a settlement agreement payment be made into a trust to avoid tax?
A: No, payments made into a trust for tax avoidance purposes are likely to be subject to anti-avoidance rules, and HMRC may still apply taxes.
Q: Is there a deadline for signing a settlement agreement?
A: There is no statutory deadline, but employers often set a timeframe for the employee to review and sign the agreement.
Q: Can you continue to receive employer-provided benefits after signing a settlement agreement?
A: This depends on the agreement, but most benefits like health insurance or car allowances typically cease after the employment ends.
Q: Is settlement agreement compensation considered as part of your annual income for tax purposes?
A: Yes, taxable payments in a settlement agreement are included in your annual income and may affect your overall tax bracket.
Q: Can you use a settlement agreement to waive your statutory redundancy rights?
A: Yes, a settlement agreement can waive statutory rights, but you should receive additional compensation for waiving these rights.
Q: Are settlement agreement payments disclosed on your P45?
A: No, settlement payments are usually reported separately to HMRC and are not included on your P45, which covers your regular earnings.
Q: Can a settlement agreement include a payment to cover future legal claims?
A: Yes, settlement agreements can include payments to cover potential future legal claims, but they will be subject to tax unless they fall under specific exemptions.
Q: Can you appeal the terms of a settlement agreement after signing it?
A: No, once a settlement agreement is signed and legally binding, you cannot appeal the terms unless there has been a breach of the agreement.
Disclaimer:
The information provided in our articles is for general informational purposes only and is not intended as professional advice. While we strive to keep the information up-to-date and correct, Pro Tax Accountant makes no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability with respect to the website or the information, products, services, or related graphics contained in the articles for any purpose. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk.
We encourage all readers to consult with a qualified professional before making any decisions based on the information provided. The tax and accounting rules in the UK are subject to change and can vary depending on individual circumstances. Therefore, Pro Tax Accountant cannot be held liable for any errors, omissions, or inaccuracies published. The firm is not responsible for any losses, injuries, or damages arising from the display or use of this information.